Efficacy

Before looking too closely at introducing Izak9 to Education Authorities globally, we wanted to ensure that we had validated it’s use as fully as possible in our own country.

To this end we have been very closely involved with our own Education Authority, our Schools Inspectorate and the teaching Universities and already have 40% of schools in Northern Ireland using Izak9 at both Primary and Secondary school level.

This page presents the findings of published research, pilot studies and teacher surveys. For more information on how Izak9 works visit our Teaching & Learning and Blog pages.

Research published in the IJER by Queen’s University, Belfast and Trinity College, Dublin

Does Izak9 raise pupils’ attitudes to mathematics?

The outcome of this research says – yes

If we take the sample of pupils surveyed across the Island of Ireland after having had exposure to using Izak9 for only six lessons, one day per week for 6 weeks, the results show that there is an increase in pupils’ attitudes to mathematics, and to a statistically significant degree, the attitudes of girls.

The context of the report showcases how 39% of boys as opposed to only 14% of girls, choose a STEM based subject at 3rd level Education (OECD 2015). The reason being that whilst girls can outperform boys in these subjects, they don’t choose them, because they don’t enjoy them.

Izak9’s use can have significant impact in this regard, when it comes to mathematics.

The study, funded by SCOTENS (Standing Council of Teacher Education North and South) involved student teachers from Queen’s University Belfast and Trinity College, Dublin.

Pilot Project Report by Education Authority Northern Ireland

Does Izak9’s use help prepare pupils for the leap from Primary to Secondary level Education?

The outcome of this EANI pilot project says - yes

A small-scale pilot of 10 schools (5 Primary and 5 partner Post Primary schools, 2 from each Education Authority region) was established in September 2015, as part of the regional Literacy and Numeracy KS2 and KS3 CPD Project, to explore the use of Izak9 as a resource to improve pupil engagement and skills in numeracy across both phases.

Key findings:

The most significant outcome from the pilot has been the impact on pupil’s skills in working with others, problem-solving and decision making, communicating mathematically and thinking flexibly. Their enjoyment and engagement have both been much higher when using Izak9, as has their confidence and willingness to take risks and try out different methods of approach.

Examples of benefits to pupils.

Benefits to Pupils Impact Evidence from visits and evaluations
To improve pupils' interest, interaction in and enjoyment of mathematics at all ability levels Significant

Enthusiasm clear in all visits to classrooms, and teachers all report pupils show much greater levels of engagement and enjoyment when using Izak9.

“Children who would normally groan at maths enjoy it.”
“From P1 up more enjoyment and engagement”
“Real buzz initially – pupils wanting to use them.”
“Less able children gained confidence”

To develop:

thinking skills and personal capabilities through collaborative/ peer learning

processing and communication skills

independent learning

Significant

97% of responses said there was some or significant impact on pupils’ skills (66% significant) with working with others.

“Izak9 has given pupils some good opportunities to practice working as part of a team in an enjoyable learning environment”

Problem solving and decision making and communicating mathematically were the next most significant. “Proper use of ‘terms’”

More grit, perseverance and willingness to try different approaches.

“More willing to tackle problems”
“Will try several ways before giving up”
“I have noticed pupils be more attentive/interested in topics after a session with Izak9.”

To provide opportunities for pupils to develop their mental maths skills

Significant

Every observed class was using mental maths strategies, and even creating their own tasks involving mental maths.

I have been able to see more clearly how the students are thinking”
“certainly helped the children with ’flexibility of thought’”

To encourage dialogue/collaboration within the class and with primary partner school.

Significant

Pupil dialogue is very significantly enhanced when using Izak9.

“More talking (even quieter ones)”
“sometimes it was useful because it uncovered misconceptions”
“pupils…were generally very open to hearing suggestions from their teammates”
“Grown in confidence in their ability to explain their mathematical thinking.”

Examples of benefits to teachers:

Benefits to Teachers  Impact Evidence from visits and evaluations
To deliver professional development for teachers Significant

Clusters/sharing practise particularly valuable. Izak9 training has been disseminated to other staff in all pilot schools. The teachers involved have recognised that Izak9 provided:

“A breath of fresh air. A completely new way to teach”
“new approaches to things”
“Think more about questioning … ‘different style of learning’”

To further teachers’ interest in and enjoyment of teaching mathematics Significant

All visits demonstrated teachers’ enjoyment of using the resource, and their enthusiasm led to trying new approaches and creating new tasks.

“Reinvigorated by pupils’ enthusiasm”
“More confident in teaching lessons where the outcome is more flexible and learning follows the children’s responses”

Conclusion of pilot

The use of the Izak9 resource has provided a new stimulus for teachers of maths and numeracy in both primary and post primary, which has proved engaging and motivating for their students. It has provided opportunities for pupils to talk about their strategies in tackling the tasks and to see that there can be a range of different approaches or even solutions to the same problem.

It has supported teachers in developing a ‘can do’ attitude, with pupils less afraid to have a go and attempt a task, when perhaps in a written format they would have taken fewer risks for learning. It has also increased their ‘stickability’ when confronted with a tougher challenge.

The kinaesthetic nature of the cubes appears to be one big advantage of this resource, with pupils very keen to use them.

The partnership aspect of the pilot worked well when teachers from both phases were brought together in a ‘formal’ setting, with many great discussions and good relationships formed. The sharing best practice day was very valuable in helping everyone to see other ways of using Izak9 in developing their pupils’ skills.

The resource ended up being used from Primary 1 right up to GCSE level in Year 11. This demonstrated the flexibility of Izak9 and the creativity of teachers in taking it and making its use relevant in a wide range of contexts.

Chief Inspector for Schools in Northern Ireland

Does the inspectorate have a positive attitude to the effective use of Izak9 in schools?

The inclusion of Izak9 in the biennial report to schools says – yes

The Chief inspector for NI schools included a photograph of Izak9 being used by pupils in her biennial report to schools. This was not a casual inclusion. The Inspectorate sent a camera team to the school and took a selection of photographs, many of which were shared during the presentation of the findings that informed the report, with the inclusion of one photograph in the report itself.

The Chief Inspector had also asked for an Izak9 session to be delivered as part of the Inspectorate’s staff development training programme. We were only too delighted to oblige and provided a fully interactive, hands on Izak9 session for all NI schools inspectors. The reason for this request was that inspectors were seeing Izak9 in use in so many schools across the country, to such positive effect, that they wished to understand fully the potential of the device and its associated pedagogy.

Teacher Response

Do teachers believe that Izak9 can raise standards in the teaching and learning of maths?

The response to this maths leaders’ survey says - yes

We were asked by the West Belfast Area Learning Community to survey the thoughts of the Secondary schools in their area that were using Izak9. Although the sample is relatively small, the findings are interesting. We thought that schools would be focusing Izak9’s use on years 8 and 9 (first and second year), but it transpires that Izak9’s use is evenly distributed across 5 years of secondary school. Obviously, children love the resource, as we already know, so pupil response rates are high, but the 2 questions that gave the most interesting responses are the 2 shown below.

These are significant statements for Secondary School Heads of Mathematics and Numeracy Coordinators to be making, especially as they would say that their relationship with mathematics would be well above average in the first instance.

We have a wealth of testimonials and anecdotal evidence from teachers, pupils and parents, principals that we can share with you upon request, but the best way for you to find out is to see Izak9 in use for yourself.

If you would like to avail of this opportunity, please request a demo.

We are most interested in requests from Schools, Teaching Universities, Maths/STEM organisations/associations, Education Boards/Authorities. We have a significant offering here, not only with Izak9 but also with its associated pedagogy and the availability of Teacher Training Courses.